Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Pony Blow openstoday’s gaggle by bickering with Terrence Hunt.

Q Iran says it’s holding the United States responsible for the safety of an Iranian diplomat who was seized by people in Iraqi uniforms, Iraqi soldier uniforms. What do you know about this?

MR. SNOW: All we know is that the Iraqi government is investigating it. And obviously, we abide by and support the Vienna Convention for diplomats. But we don’t really know a lot about it at this point. We know that the Iraqi government is investigating.

Q And is the United States — can it confirm that Iraqi soldiers took this person?

MR. SNOW: Again, I think you — refer all that to the Iraqi government. We’ve seen the news reports. We’re not in the business of confirming. They’re investigating. I would refer you to the people doing the investigation.

Q Do we know, did it happen?

MR. SNOW: I’ve seen news reports, again, Terry —

Q Nothing more than that?

MR. SNOW: Terry, you know who to call, or you know who to have your people call.

Q I’m starting with you.

MR. SNOW: All right, and I’m telling you that this is something that the Iraqis are investigating.

Obsession continues…

Continue reading “Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle”

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The NIE Spin

NSA Steve Hadley was spining like a top today.

There Is Nothing Civil About This War

Q Mr. Hadley, the report also says, the term “civil war” accurately describes key elements of the Iraqi conflict. Is the President ready to embrace that term, as well?

MR. HADLEY: One of the things that is helpful — and this is on page two — is a statement that the intelligence community judges that the term “civil war” does not adequately capture the complexity of the conflict in Iraq. And we think that is right.

[snip]

Q Does it mean that the President does accept that civil war accurately describes key elements — does he accept that?

MR. HADLEY: I think what the President does is he accepts the description of the key elements — that is that there’s a hardening of ethno-sectarian identities, a sea change in the character of the violence, ethno-sectarian mobilization, and population displacements. The facts are not in dispute, and they are what drove the policy. And the policy seeks to try and respond to those facts and come up with a strategy that will succeed. That’s what our task is and that’s what we’ve done.

[snip]

Q Mr. Hadley, I want to go back to the term “civil war.” The administration has really gone out of its way not to use that term, “civil war,” in the same way that Don Rumsfeld wouldn’t call it a “guerilla war” when it was, or an “insurgency” when it was. Why do you go out of your way not to use that word? The President goes out of his way, as well. You say labels are difficult, but is it not important — certainly any military strategist will tell you it’s important to know what kind of fight you’re in. Can you call it a civil war, and why haven’t you?

MR. HADLEY: We know what kind of fight we’re in. We know the facts. That is described well in this NIE, and we have a strategy to deal with those facts and to try to succeed.

Q Is it a civil war?

MR. HADLEY: I will tell you what this NIE says.

Q I want to know why you avoid using that term.

MR. HADLEY: Because it’s not an adequate description of the situation we find ourselves, as the intelligence community says. Intelligence judges “the term civil war does not adequately capture the complexities of the conflict in Iraq.” And what we’re doing is saying, if you’re going to run policy, and if you’re going to explain it to the American people, we need to get across the complexities of the situation we face in Iraq, and what is our strategy to deal with that. And simple labels don’t do that. We’re going to try and force everybody to get into the facts.

[snip]

Q Going back to the civil war, the use of that term, is it fair to say, or accurate to say that it is now beyond a civil war, because that would imply that you have the elements of a civil war and yet there is — there are additional factors?

MR. HADLEY: I think I can’t do better than the description of the facts on the ground that is in the NIE with which we agree, and that says this is a complex, difficult situation. And that’s what it is.

The spinning continues…

Continue reading “Today On Holden’s Obsession With The NIE Spin”

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

It’s gagle time again.

Looks Like Someone Has Been Ignoring The Advice of the Commanders on the Ground

Q General Casey testified today that securing Baghdad would take fewer than half the additional troops that President Bush has proposed, and he said that he had asked for two brigades, based on the recommendations of his subordinate commanders. So how did we wind up with five additional brigades?

MR. SNOW: Well, the President has talked with — you also know that General Casey supports the plan. And the plan is to bring in five brigades into Baghdad, and also another 4,000 Marines into Anbar, not only to take care of immediate security concerns, but to make sure that we have adequate force structure as the Iraqis begin bringing brigades into each of the nine districts of Baghdad, and the Americans also into those nine districts, in support, that we have adequate resources and forces to deal not only with the media, but also potential threats to security.

Q But why the disparity in numbers? When he’s talking on the Hill about asking for two, and the President asked for five?

MR. SNOW: Well, there were a number of conversations, and the President, after talking with General Casey and other commanders, came to the conclusion that he preferred to have five brigades into Baghdad and 4,000 Marines into Anbar. And again, what General Casey was talking about is some suggestions he’d made earlier. The President has made his decision, and it does reflect the wisdom of a number of combatant commanders. And again, it does have the assent of General Casey.

Q Let me get one more. General Casey, do you think that he’s kind of been all over the park on this? He’s first of all, said that additional troops weren’t warranted, and then he went along with the President, and now he’s saying this?

MR. SNOW: No, I think what you’ve had is you had a shifting series of circumstances within Baghdad.

[snip]

Q Can I just go back to the question about General Casey and the brigade, saying he felt fewer than half of what the President has planned were needed. You say he supports the plan now. He says he does, but it seems like a very diplomatic way to say, not really, and I don’t have to be there to carry it out. So who did the President rely on heavily when he made these decisions? The commander on the ground did not, it appears, agree with the President’s bigger, larger plan for more brigades. The commander of Central Command apparently did not. So the President relied mostly on outside people, or the people who he was trying to get to go in —

MR. SNOW: I’ve often been asked about internal deliberations, and I’ve always given the same answer, which is, I’m not going to characterize them. It is worth noting that General Abizaid and General Casey, both of whom you’ve described as being in opposition to the plan, publicly have supported it. And so I’ll let you —

Q But what he said today didn’t quite fit that, Tony.

MR. SNOW: I’d refer the questions back to him and I let him clarify.

Obseesion Continues in Extended Text…

Continue reading “Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle”

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Just a quickie gaggle as Chimpy heads to New York. Pony sounds none too confident about the Iranian link to the attack on US forces that the Pentagon lied about last week. Q On a different subject, how confident are you that Iran was behind the agents that killed those five soldiers in Karbala? MR. SNOW: I’m not getting into that sort of speculation. I’d send you off to the Department of Defense for any readout they’re going to give. But let me just reiterate what the President said — we’re going to do force protection and people who are … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today’sgaggle opens with Pony Blow doing his best to belittle this weekend’s peace march. Helen. Q What did the President think of the march on Washington? MR. SNOW: I don’t think he really thought a lot about it. It’s nice to see Jane Fonda in front of the camera again. There are a number of people who were here making statements, and that’s perfectly appropriate. This is a vigorous democracy. Q You said something earlier this morning, though. Would you like to repeat that? MR. SNOW: It’s simply that there were predictions of a larger audience than showed up for … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

A side note before we begin: Typepad still can’t figure out that I’m me instead of someone else, so Athenae has graciously allowed me to log in as her until they recognize me as me again. But I really am me. Anyway, Pony Blow did a quickie gaggle aboard Air Force One this morning en route to Kansas City where Chimpy is due to prattle on about his dumbass health care proposal. However, none of the gagglers were interested in Chimpy’s plan to raise taxes on some while further denying helath care to others, they were primarily intereseted in Iraq. … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Intoday’s gaggle Pony Blow assures us that 27 US deaths and three times that number of Iraqis killed is simply good PR work by our “enemies”. Q Over the weekend we just had the third worst day in the war in terms of U.S. casualties, and then today I think there were 70 people killed in Baghdad. Is the President going to talk about the extent, the increase in violence and what can be done about it? MR. SNOW: Well, he has talked about it. And the President also noted the other day that what’s really going on is that … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Pony Blow must be out… I don’t know, blowing ponies or something — because Dana Peroxide handled today’s gaggle.Dana is nothing if not a True Believer. Q Just days before the State of the Union, there is a back and forth, escalating and escalating. How is the President handling this back and forth, up and down Pennsylvania Avenue, as he’s getting ready to deliver this major speech? Is he weary a bit? Because we’re hearing some things that he may be a little bit tired from the Iraq fight? MS. PERINO: I was fortunate enough to see him yesterday in … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

In today’s gaggle, Helen Thomas follows up on her line of questioning from yesterday. Go ahead, Helen. Q I’d like to revisit a question yesterday. You said that we would not submit to a referendum from the Iraqis on our military presence. MR. SNOW: You’re talking about a — I thought you were talking about a referendum within the United States. Q No. No, in Iraq. MR. SNOW: Oh, well, the Iraqis can do whatever they want politically. I’m sorry, I completely misunderstood that question. Q Well, I want to continue this question. Even if you said, no, you wouldn’t. … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle

I’m not sure how this is going to work in the new digs, seein’ as how Obsession tends to go on and on, and I’ve lost my Read More button, but here goes. Let’s kick it off withHelen, who seems to hold the odd belief that Iraqis should determine the future of Iraq (and draws the dreaded Civil War comparison out of Pony Blow). Q Would the administration agree to a referendum in Iraq to see what the people really want? MR. SNOW: No. Q Why? MR. SNOW: The federal Constitution does not permit for such referenda. Q Why? We … Continue reading Today On Holden’s Obsession With The Gaggle