Libby Unqualified for Pardon

Newsweek’s Michael Isikoff and Mark Hosenball rain on Scooter’s parade.

But there’s one significant roadblock on the path to Libby’s salvation: Vice President Dick Cheney’s former chief of staff does not qualify to even be considered for a presidential pardon under Justice Department guidelines.

From the day he took office, Bush seems to have followed those guidelines religiously. He’s taken an exceedingly stingy approach to pardons, granting only 113 in six years, mostly for relatively minor fraud, embezzlement and drug cases dating back more than two decades. Bush’s pardons are “fewer than any president in 100 years,” according to Margaret Love, former pardon attorney at the Justice Department.


The president has since indicated he intended to go by the book in granting what few pardons he’d hand out—considering only requests that had first been reviewed by the Justice Department under a series of publicly available guidelines.

Those regulations, which are discussed on the Justice Department Web site at, would seem to make a Libby pardon a nonstarter in George W. Bush’s White House. They “require a petitioner to wait a period of at least five years after conviction or release from confinement (whichever is later) before filing a pardon application,” according to the Justice Web site.

Moreover, in weighing whether to recommend a pardon, U.S. attorneys are supposed to consider whether an applicant is remorseful. “The extent to which a petitioner has accepted responsibility for his or her criminal conduct and made restitution to … victims are important considerations. A petitioner should be genuinely desirous of forgiveness rather than vindication,” the Justice Web site states.

7 thoughts on “Libby Unqualified for Pardon

  1. Bush also said he’d fire anyone involved in this mess.
    Rove still has a job. Everyone still has a job.
    He’ll pardon Libby and never think twice about it. Especially if someone tells him Bill Clinton wouldn’t pardon Libby.

  2. no, Bush 1 pardon’s were for ronnie raygun era. so i think they made it to 5 years.
    but did any of them get jail time?

  3. What a bunch of wasted words at Newsweek. All the respect shown by the Bush administration for the rule of law or guidelines of any kind could be dropped onto the head of a pin and not roll off.
    Libby will be pardoned any moment now. Hell, they’ll probably do it just because they know it’ll make us all apoplectic. I recommend not getting furious in advance.

  4. Those guidelines don’t seem to have mattered when Bush’s father pardoned Weinburger his Iran-Contra charges before they even got to court.

  5. Abu Gonzales will merely argue that since the preznit does not wait five years from conviction in the case of the pardons of Thanksgiving turkeys, he does not need to wait five years to pardon loyal Republican fall guys who keep their traps shut.

Comments are closed.