
I have been an online forum moderator twice in my life. It’s a kind of miserable volunteering gig in many cases.
One of the things you have to deal with is trolls. An online troll is an individual who intentionally posts provocative, offensive, or disruptive content on the internet to elicit strong emotional reactions or disrupt conversations. In other words, an asshole.
So, based on this experience, I can recognize a troll rather quickly. And I also know that trolls do not exist only online, they can work their dark shitty magic in real life.
This leads me to my Democratic senator, John Fetterman. I volunteered in his senate campaign, felt horrible when he had his stroke, and defended him against jerks who mocked his poor post-stroke debate performance. I liked him because he was a smart progressive who often made many great points, and when he won, I was over the moon.
The honeymoon didn’t last. In fact, it was surprisingly short. Seemingly starting after the Hamas terror attack and Israel’s over-the-top vicious right-wing-driven response, Fetterman became more of a troll that was punching down, not up.
Part of Fetterman’s style has always been snark. For example, during his senate campaign he had a plane flying at South Jersey beaches trailing a message about his opponent, Dr. Oz, actually living in New Jersey and not Pennsylvania. Shrewd move, given so many southeast Pennsylvania folks head to those beaches in the summer.
But soon after the Hamas terror attack and while Israel was responding by killing children, pro-Palestinian protestors showed up outside Fetterman’s home. He responded by taunting them by waving an Israeli flag from his roof.
This of course infuriated a lot of Democrats, and Fetterman seemed to revel in it. The right wing loved it and soon began to heap praise on Fetterman.
Fetterman openly trolled Crooked Senator Bob Menendez by hiring George Santos to make a video mocking him. I agreed with his overall point but paying Santos was an odd move. More recently he referred to Trump’s picking sex offender Matt Gaetz as his attorney general nominee as “god-level trolling” to “own the libs” and he sounded less like he found that to be bad and more like professional admiration of a fellow practitioner of a craft. As you probably have noticed, trolling is a key part of being MAGA.
Fetterman also did a Trump thumbs-up pose with Elise Stefanik and talked about how excited he was that the MAGA congresscretin was going to be our ambassador to the UN, including sounding a lot like a far-right Republican about making the UN pay for not supporting Israel. And yesterday, he announced he will be the first Democratic senator to meet with Donald Trump at Mar-A-Lago.
These are all troll moves. Part of a troll’s game is to do things that are upsetting, enraging, and hurtful to their target but also leave just enough plausible deniability. The “who me?” bullshit that is a form of gaslighting is key for the troll. This is because it enables them to enlist people who will say “How do you know that’s what they meant?” as unknowing pawns to inflict even more damage. Fetterman knows this, much in the way Krysten Sinema knew what she was doing when she wore the Fuck Off ring in that infamous social media photo.
You might be tempted to say, big deal, so he’s a jerk, there’s so much else to worry about. The problem is that a lot of Democrats, especially younger Democrats, voted for Fetterman based on how he presented himself. He can gaslight all he wants (another symptom of a troll) about how he never said he was progressive, but do a search on news articles about him prior to his election to the Senate. The funny/sad/pathetic thing to me is I have noted that some of the people who seem to agree with him that he was never a progressive are also the same exact people who used to say he could never get elected to anything beyond small-town mayor because he was too far left.
Don’t feed the trolls.
So, many of those voters feel conned, disillusioned, and turned off of politics. Screaming vote harder at them is simply not going to work, and it makes one look sort of silly because a lot of that crowd goes on about how progressives can’t win elections, and then promote telling part of the base how much they suck, and well, yeah, that isn’t a defensible opinion.
None of us who voted for Fetterman voted for MAGA’s favorite Democrat. And I’ll close with that.
The last word goes to John Lennon.

I fully expect him to be the deciding vote against some progressive bill, and to curtsy like Kyrsten Sinema when he does.
Sigh…I live in Texas, but I contributed money to Fetterman because he was fresh and snarky and seemed to be the shake-up the stuffed shirts in the Senate needed. He is not the first disappointment I have felt from a politician, but I really miss his humor and what I thought was a laser-focus on truth.
I am not kidding when I advocate for testing the drinking water on Capitol Hill…I mean WTF?! Why do reason and logic and truth disappear so quickly? What is being added to the drinking fountains? I am, of course, assuming that Cheney, Kinzinger, and most Dems bring bottled water to work to avoid the poisoning.
As Mencken would say to people who disagreed with him: “You may be right.” Fetterman might be pulling a Sinema-esque switcheroo, and bad on him if that’s the case.
I am willing (by a 36-34-30 plurality) to grant Sen. Fetterman the benefit of the doubt for playing footsie with the felon ( paraphrasing “Trump asked to meet with me, it’s reasonable for me to meet with him”) and for helping the Lakin Riley bill advance (under the guise of more expeditiously deporting undocumented immigrants with criminal records convicted of crimes in the U.S.).
What I want to see is how Fetterman conducts himself when what we can all see is about to happen happens. When the felon betrays the country – again – does Fetterman call him out? When a newly-empowered ICE and Border Patrol go back to caging children, separating families, and sending refugees and asylum seekers back to their home countries to face certain death, does Fetterman stand athwart history and yell, “Stop!”? Or does he shrug and mutter something about eggs and omelets or intone that “nobody could have foreseen” these atrocities?
I hope Fetterman’s constituents (and Gallego’s in Arizona) press their Senator to do the right thing, the humanitarian thing, the Shining City on a Hill thing when things start to go sideways, as we suspect they will.
You know who else campaigned as a progressive as defined at the time? Bill Clinton. Go back and read his speeches from his first campaign. Same goes for Obama. Robert Reich didn’t quit Clinton just for the fun of it.